On november 29th, the first new outbreak of foot and mouth disease (FMD) was reported in North Gyeong-Sang province in South Korea. The South Korean government failed controlling the disease at an early stage and now the highly contagious disease has been reported in five another provinces. The government and the officials did their best but to no vail. The lethal disease to cloven-hoofed animals does not seem to restrain from spreading.
As a measure to control such highly contagious disease, mass slaughters were taken place and it was in record numbers. It is unavoidable to kill animals in order to prevent the disease from spreading. However, the procedures of killing animals for disease control purpose should be conducted in a way that meets the international standards for animal welfare.
However, it is reported that thousands of pigs have been buried alive as part of the control. Since the outbreak of the FMD, over 470,000 animals, four percent of South Korea's livestocks have been either culled or destined for slaughter. Live burial of animals is a breach of the World Organisation for Anmal Health's (OIE) guideline on the Killing of Animals for Disease Control Purposes. Since South Korea is a member of the OIE it should observe the guidelines. The guideline says "When animals are killed for disease control purposes, methods used should result in immediate death or immediate loss of consciousness lasting until death; when loss of consciousness is not immediate, induction of unconsciousness should be non-aversive or the least aversive possible and should not cause avoidable anxiety, pain, distress or suffering in animals.”
Some people who put priority to human interest over animal welfare may say that considering animal welfare into the measure is inefficient in controlling the disease, causing more economic damage. Their argument is based on a premise that since animal do not have emotion, they do not deserve any rights. It is true that animals do not have sophisticated emotion like human, such as feeling depressed by one's social status even though they have enough to live on or being amazed at 3D movies and etc. However, when it comes to death, the fear and pain which animals feel are no less than those of human. The fact that human enjoy more delicate feelings does not lead to the fact that animals have less fear of pain in front of death. People even say that human has the right to die in dignity. It does not need to be to this extent, but the slaughter should be completed as quickly as possible in order to minimize the pain and distress that animals might have during the process.
However, the most preffered approah dealing with FMD, from the standpoint of animal welfare advocate, would be the vaccination. The OIE distinguish states into three kinds concerning FMD; FMD present with or without vaccination, FMD-free with vaccination and FME-free without vaccination. Countries that are designated as FMD-free without vaccination have the greatest access to export markets because there is a possibility that the disease might remain in the body of the vaccinated animals. Therefore, it is difficult to regain FMD-free witouth vaccination status and this is the reason why governments try not to use it when such emergency disease outbreaks.

